The Lost Men Grahamstown: the first counter-memorial
Updated: 1 day ago

In July 2004, ten years after South Africa’s first democratic elections, I installed The Lost Men Grahamstown beside the 1820 Settlers National Monument on Gunfire Hill, in what is now Makhanda. It was the first installation in The Lost Men series and formed part of the National Arts Festival’s main programme.
I pressed names of men who died in the Eastern Cape Wars of Dispossession into my skin with lead type. The archives preserved military ranks and names, but the Xhosa names I could find were recorded singly in the journals of white soldiers. That difference in how names had been recorded mattered at a site built to commemorate the settlers.
I returned to the work in a 2018 post about a photograph from the project shown in Wounds and Relics at Gallery 2, Johannesburg, 1–22 September 2018. The installation photograph below shows the banners in the landscape where the series began.
Installation on Gunfire Hill, July 2004
First photograph by Suzy Bernstein, showing the silk banners with the 1820 Settlers National Monument behind them. Reproduced from the Wits Art Museum monograph (2020), pp. 34–35. Courtesy of the Grahamstown National Arts Festival and Art Source South Africa.
The view of the banners lifting in the wind is by Paul Emmanuel. Additional views are from the Studio’s project archive.
Watch the 2004 installation film. Filmed by the Rhodes University Department of Journalism and Media Studies.
Three source photographs for the banners
Photographs by Andrew Meintjes. Courtesy of Art Source South Africa.
Documentary sources
PUBLISHED SOURCES
2020 · Irene Bronner, ‘The material of mourning,’ Image & Text, no. 34. Later independent scholarly analysis of The Lost Men installations.
2016 · U.S. Department of State, Paul Emmanuel artist profile. Later official biography independently documenting the early counter-memorial sequence.
2 July 2004 · Dianne Tipping-Woods, ‘Hanging on the Hill,’ Cue, p. 6. Contemporaneous on-site report and photograph of The Lost Men installed on Monument Hill, with remarks by the artist.
4 July 2004 · Yvette Greslé, ‘Wars Incarnated,’ Cue, p. 6. Contemporaneous independent review describing and photographing the 21-banner installation on Monument Hill.
STUDIO ARCHIVE
30 November 2003 · National Arts Festival — selection and support letter. Institutional correspondence identifying The Lost Men for the 2004 festival main programme.
July 2004 · National Arts Festival — official souvenir programme. Contemporaneous printed programme identifying Paul Emmanuel and the site-specific installation.
Selected unpublished documents are held in the Paul Emmanuel Studio archive. Copies may be requested for research purposes by emailing studio@paulemmanuel.net. Requests are considered individually, subject to permissions and intended use.
Related content


